“Did not see that coming”: When Mayim Bialik recalled Amy and Sheldon’s The Big Bang Theory bedroom episode

For a science-titled sitcom of social unease and sarcasm, The Big Bang Theory had some tricks up its sleeve. One of the biggest surprises—and one of the most talked about—across the show's twelve-year-run was when Sheldon Cooper and Amy Farrah Fowler took their relationship to a physical level in Season 9, Episode 11, The Opening Night Excitation.

Mayim Bialik, who acted out Amy with scholarly and comedic accuracy, even publicly discussed the fact that she was taken aback by how the relationship progressed. In an interview with The Paley Center for Media, Mayim Bialik exclaimed,

"We did not see that coming."

In her honest remembrance, Bialik did not dramatize the scene, nor did she make it seem romantic. She gave an honest take on the scene—how it was to her as an individual and as an actress. She testified that Amy sharing kisses with Sheldon came as a surprise to her when she read the script for the first time.

Since both of the characters in The Big Bang Theory had been created in script as being emotionally shut down and opposed to the old romantic stereotypes, the big jump to intimacy felt surprising—but somehow, in some warped kind of way, it felt right. The writers, she also said, did it correctly, with dignity and respect, choosing realism over sensationalism.

---

The slow-burn evolution of Shamy in The Big Bang Theory

In Season 5, Episode 10, The Flaming Spittoon Acquisition, Sheldon asks Amy out as his girlfriend when he catches her conversing with Stuart. This gesture, while couched in Sheldon's usually scientific language, creates an increasingly emotionally engaged narrative between these two actors. The episode is also marked by the introduction of the now-notorious Relationship Agreement, whereby they negotiate the terms of their relationship to ludicrously detailed effect.

Amy sets about pushing Sheldon towards greater intimacy from then on, either with ostensibly innocent emotional lure or increasingly bald experiments (as in Episode 23, The Launch Acceleration).

In this The Big Bang Theory episode, experimentally, Amy tries flirting with Sheldon—faking illness so that Sheldon could offer a sympathetic ear. There is no physical contact or "bedroom scene" yet. The developing romance is still platonic in Season 5.

---

Character development over time in The Big Bang Theory

The Big Bang Theory is not about physical intimacy but about an emotional foundation formed between Amy and Sheldon. The writers proceeded to display a true, respectful manner in relationships formed at an odd tempo throughout Season 5. Sheldon, who is socially inept and emotionally closed off, finds methods for learning how to fit someone else's needs—something not feasible in previous seasons.

Amy's emotional IQ, persistence, and patience in The Big Bang Theory are key to that growth. She doesn't attempt to change Sheldon; she lets him reach emotional conclusions in his own good time.

This is a season full of funny but telling moments: Sheldon walking Amy home and being hesitant to proclaim that she is his girlfriend, and bringing up their Relationship Agreement as an offer of togetherness rather than alienation.

---

Why the timeline matters in The Big Bang Theory

We need to know when events actually happened to truly understand the show's pacing and storytelling choices. Adding later information in hindsight may seem easy, but it distorts the careful character development built over years. It also overlooks the writers’ intentional decision to wait until Season 9 to suggest that Sheldon and Amy had a physical relationship.

It also changes the context of Mayim Bialik's surprise. Her surprise stemmed from the fact that the show had done such an excellent job of building it up slowly. That shock is so much more special when coupled with the proper episode and timeline.

---

To fully see the real arc of Sheldon and Amy's relationship, The Big Bang Theory had to be seen as a setup and not a peak. It had established a shift in Sheldon that would make future intimacy possible. It left space for Amy to show her emotional demands, and it provided viewers with a glimpse of Sheldon attempting—although failing—to meet them.

Mayim Bialik's comments provide an appropriate background in which to place this development. And perhaps that is why the brooding narration of the show's "Shamy" is one of its best-written plots.

Also read: The Big Bang Theory Season 5 finale recap: Howard and Bernadette’s wedding takes off before liftoff