Dateline: A Sister's Search - Who was Aasha Davis and what happened to her sister Lesley Herring? Disturbing details of the 2009 homicide, revisited 

Dateline's A Sister's Search is a summary of the 2009 disappearance and later murder case of Lesley Herring, the sister of actress Aasha Davis. The Los Angeles case remained unsolved for over a year before culminating in the arrest and conviction of Lesley's husband, Lyle Stanford Herring Jr. The program provides the chronology of events that led to the investigation, arrest, and trial without speculation beyond reported facts.

Lesley Herring was last heard from on February 8, 2009. She was 44 and had a job in human resources. Dateline details her timeline as attending a Super Bowl party with her husband on the morning of that day. After she had returned home, she was not heard from again. Her failure to report for work or contact her family raised alarm with the authorities. A missing persons report was lodged shortly thereafter.

The background of Lesley Herring

Lesley Herring lived in Los Angeles with her husband of one year, Lyle Herring. Coworkers allegedly stated that she was always punctual and dependable. Her sudden absence was noticed by her employer, who then contacted her family. Lesley's younger sister, Aasha Davis, was in a state of instant worry since she had heard nothing from her sister at all.

Police officials opened an investigation. Preliminary checks showed no usage of Lesley's phone, accounts, and social media platforms after February 8. All these facts, uncovered in Dateline, brought forth the growing suspicion that her disappearance could have been caused by criminal action.

The investigation focuses on Lyle Herring

Lyle Stanford Herring Jr. was among the initial persons of interest in the case. Based on Dateline, he initially told officials that Lesley left their apartment following a fight. Witness testimony and video footage challenged aspects of his statement. Officers noted inconsistencies between what he said and did.

Further investigation revealed that Lyle never informed Lesley’s family or the police of her disappearance in the first few days following her disappearance. Detectives subsequently learned that he had flushed items that belonged to Lesley. All this was circumstantial evidence used in building a case, as explained in the Dateline show.

Arrest and prosecution

In April 2010, more than one year after Lesley Herring had disappeared, Lyle Herring was arrested and charged with the murder of Lesley. The case proceeded to trial without the discovery of her body. The Los Angeles District Attorney's Office tried the case based on circumstantial evidence, including inconsistencies in Lyle's explanation, lack of physical evidence that Lesley had left voluntarily, and his conduct since her disappearance.

Witnesses during the trial had testified to the couple's relationship and the couple's last known activities. Prosecutors had been arguing that the timeline and activity provided by Lyle Herring warranted a second-degree murder conviction. A jury found him guilty in 2013. He received a sentence ranging from 15 years to life in prison. As Dateline explained, this conviction stood despite no body.

Public scrutiny and family response

Aasha Davis stayed involved throughout the investigation and trial. Her public demands for information prompted media coverage of the case. Dateline says she worked with detectives and stayed committed to finding out what happened. She has been open about the impact the case had on her and her family.

Although a conviction was secured, the remains of Lesley Herring were not recovered. As Dateline has it, having no physical remains leaves loose ends. The final legal determination did not provide the total closure that recovery would have provided.

The case was revisited on Dateline

The Dateline television show A Sister's Search is a summary of the case, the investigation, and the trial. The show reruns comments from family members, lawyers, and investigators who handled the case. It highlights how difficult it is to prove murder cases based on no physical evidence and how pressure from the family kept the case open.

Dateline offers hard evidence from public records, trial records, and on-the-scene interviews. The show has a timeline of the case progression from missing persons report to murder conviction, with emphasis on the legal and investigative mistakes along the way.

This episode gives a comprehensive account of the 2009 murder and vanishing of Lesley Herring. One of the distinguishing factors of the case is Lyle Herring's conviction, with the body never recovered. The program reviews the legal and investigative process, as it relates to the emotional toll borne by the victims' families.

Trending

The case is still used as a reference when addressing prosecuting no-body murders and the importance of early intervention when an adult goes missing. Objective in their reporting, Dateline gives a fact-based account of the case without speculation, resulting in the audience having a better understanding of the case and its lasting effect.

Also read: You can’t deny these 10 Dateline episodes were more than what you expected

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback